ingle Mother

Thursday 14 January 2010

by: Dahr Jamail, t r u t h o u t | Report

photo
Army Spc. Alexis Hutchinson with son Kamani Hutchinson. (Photo: Alexis Hutchinson / Oakland Tribune)

The Army has filed charges for a special court-martial against Spc. Alexis Hutchinson, a single mother of a one-year-old baby. Hutchinson missed her deployment to Afghanistan late last year when her child-care plans for her son, Kamani, fell through at the last minute.

Hutchinson and her attorneys had been working with the Army in good faith to resolve her situation administratively, rather than through the criminal process, and still hoped that would have been the most fair and compassionate way for the Army to deal with the difficult situation.

Maj. Daniel Gallagher is the rear detachment commander of the 3rd Infantry Division, and is, according to Hutchinson's civilian attorney Rai Sue Sussman, "the one who signed the charges [against Hutchinson]."

"I am disappointed in Major Daniel Gallagher's decision to go ahead with filing charges, which shows a lack of compassion for this young mother and her infant son, and a lack of discretion in dealing with the situation fairly," Sussman wrote in a press release issued on Thursday. "The situation tends to show that the Army is not able to effectively and humanely counsel Army families in this situation. An infant and his mother were forcibly separated, when other options were available to the commander. This was a failure of her chain of command to properly counsel her, given her situation. On top of all this, criminal charges seem unnecessary."

Sussman explained that the Army claims to have offered to counsel Hutchinson with other options, but said she "can't imagine that they gave an offer beyond foster care - but they were unspecific in their press release [released Thursday] about what that child care would be."

The military's press release on the matter stated that Hutchinson's command had informed her of other options to take care of her child, but that she had refused these options.

Sussman said she speaks with Hutchinson regularly, and knows that government care for her infant is not something her client wants to do.

In previous instances when soldiers deploy and leave a child in state custody, when the parent returns they often experience problems in exercising their parental rights, and in some cases have even lost custody of their child.

Sussman explained to Truthout that she was taken aback by the Army's recent decision, particularly when she felt that negotiations were making progress.

"First we offered and put in an application for a Chapter 5A discharge for parenthood, which is an honorable discharge," she said, "But more recently we were willing to take a misconduct discharge to get things over with. But her commander rejected that and filed criminal charges. Hutchinson would really just like to put this all behind her."

Sussman feels that "in terms of equity and efficiency, and even punishment, I think the Army could do this a different way than a special court martial."

If Hutchinson is found guilty during a special court-martial, she could face up to a one year detention in a military brig, forfeiture of a percentage or all of her pay while in jail and has a guarantee she will not receive an honorable discharge from the military upon completion of her jail time, thereby forfeiting at least some, and likely all, of her benefits.

"To me, when we are willing to get an other-than-honorable discharge for the purposes of ending this situation and having some stability for her child, it's disappointing that he [Major Gallagher] feels it needs to be a criminal charge," Sussman told Truthout, "They are throwing the book at her, even though she's already been punished a lot. She's had her child taken away from her, she did three days in jail when she was arrested in November, then three weeks on 24-hour watch sleeping on a cot in the recreation room [at her barracks] after that, and then assigned to post."

Currently, Hutchinson remains assigned to Hunter Army Airfield near Savannah, Georgia, where she has been posted since February 2008.

In mid-November 2009, Hutchinson was jailed and threatened with a court-martial if she did not agree to deploy to Afghanistan. At the time, her son was placed into a county foster care system.

Prior to this, Hutchinson was, according to the family care plan of the US Army, allowed to fly to California and leave her son with her mother, Angelique Hughes of Oakland.

However, after a week of caring for the child, Hughes realized she was unable to care for Kamani along with her other duties of caring for a daughter with special-needs, her ailing mother and an ailing sister.

In late October, Angelique Hughes told Hutchinson and her commander, Captain Gassant, that she would be unable to care for Kamani after all. The Army then gave Hutchinson an extension of time in order to enable her to find someone else to care for Kamani. Meanwhile, Hughes brought Kamani back to Georgia to be with his mother.

However, only a few days before Hutchinson's original deployment date, she was told by the Army she would not get the time extension after all, and would have to deploy, despite not having found anyone to care for her child.

Faced with this choice, Specialist Hutchinson chose not to show up for her plane to Afghanistan. The military arrested her and placed her child in the county foster care system.

At that time, Sussman told Truthout, "I think they didn't believe her that she was unable to find someone to care for her infant. They think she's just trying to get out of her deployment. But she's just trying to find someone she can trust to take care of her baby. She has never intended to get out of her deployment."

Hutchinson's mother flew to Georgia and took temporary custody of the baby, but was quickly overwhelmed and did not feel able to provide long-term care for the child.

At the time, Sussman told Truthout that the Army's JAG attorney, Capt. Ed Whitford "told me they thought her chain of command thought she was trying to get out of her deployment by using her child as an excuse."

Major Gallagher also told Sussman in November that he did not believe it was a real family crisis, and that Hutchinson's "mother should have been able to take care of the baby."

In addition, according to Sussman, a First Sergeant Gephart "told me he thought she [Hutchinson] was pulling her family care plan stuff to get out of her deployment."

Sussman hopes that they are able to resolve the situation with a good solution for Hutchinson, "where she's not separated from her child and not given a criminal conviction. So I hope she can either beat the court martial or find a good resolution by working with the Army. But I'm pretty frustrated that they still want to punish her, even though she's been fully cooperative with them from the very beginning."

When Hutchinson returned from her holiday break last week, she brought Kamani with her. According to Sussman, Hutchinson hopes that if she is taken to jail again, she is given notice so that she can make proper arrangements for her son.

Sussman is clear about what she feels the Army has done to mishandle the situation: "The whole situation arose in large part because it was a failure of her chain of command to properly counsel her when this began, and now they are still failing to give her compassion and discretion when her child is involved, and they are treating her like there is no child involved and there was no excuse for her not to show up. When in reality, she was forced to choose between her child and her mission, which is obviously a difficult choice."

Creative Commons License
This work by Truthout is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial 3.0 United States License.


»

Dahr Jamail, an independent journalist, is the author of "The Will to Resist: Soldiers Who Refuse to Fight in Iraq and Afghanistan," (Haymarket Books, 2009), and "Beyond the Green Zone: Dispatches From an Unembedded Journalist in Occupied Iraq," (Haymarket Books, 2007). Jamail reported from occupied Iraq for nine months as well as from Lebanon, Syria, Jordan and Turkey over the last five years.
Comments

This forum is moderated by software. Please allow up to 15 minutes for your comments to go live and avoid posting the same comment multiple times.
Can you IMAGINE the GALL of
Thu, 01/14/2010 - 17:31 — Dana (not verified)
Can you IMAGINE the GALL of our government that has murdered, in Iraq alone, over 1.5 million CIVILIANS, with cluster bombs and white phosphorous, now having the NERVE to turn its Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde authoritarian and military personality on a single mother who opts to take care of her child over participating in a neoliberal takeover of the mideast.
Here we go again: the US
Thu, 01/14/2010 - 17:40 — Anonymous (not verified)
Here we go again: the US military freaks out when its authority is challenged. How insecure are they? Especially folks like this "major" who filed the criminal charges. Wonder how well he'd do against a well-trained, determined enemy with the same resources as the US. Please: don't say this is about "discipline"; pure crap.
I thought we had a military
Thu, 01/14/2010 - 18:57 — TFT (not verified)
I thought we had a military to preserve our democracy. I thought part of that democracy was respect for the citizens that make up that democracy. How does destroying a family, potentially ruining a parent/child relationship, and making a citizen choose between this war and her child help to preserve democracy?
I just looked up this story,
Thu, 01/14/2010 - 19:06 — The Todd (not verified)
I just looked up this story, and I see quite a bit Truthout left out. Such as Sussman had 4 days to let her superiors know what was up after her mother decided she couldn't care for the baby, but never contacted them. She didn't contact ANYONE in the military offices. She just didn't show up for her deployment. Also left out was the fact that if she DID contact her superiors about the situation, even a DAY before her deployment, they would not have deployed her. She never contacted anyone in the hierarchy. There is a lot more that was not put into the Digg, that would show this isn't just the Army's fault. A lot of the blame goes to Sussman, and I have a small feeling that this wasn't the real reason she missed the date.
Add a comment:
Name
Your name:
Email
E-mail:
The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
Comment
Comment: *

More information about formatting options


Homepage:
Subject:
Signup for updates
Search

Follow Truthout on Twitter
MOST POPULAR

*

President Obama, the CIA and the Master of the Cover-Up

by: Melvin A. Goodman, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

*

Factory Farmed Meat Can Trigger a Global Pandemic That Wipes Out Sixty Percent of Those Infected

by: Kathy Freston | AlterNet

*

Answering Helen Thomas on Why They Want to Harm Us

by: Ray McGovern, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed

*

Three Approved GMO's Linked to Organ Damage

by: Rady Ananda, t r u t h o u t | Op-Ed


Show your support for truthout with these great new member gifts!
Digg
What is Digg?
Recent Popular Truthout stories on Digg

* 1000 diggs
ACLU Blasts Obama For Continuing to Cover-Up Bush War Crimes

Obama has substituted words for action on issues surrounding torture accountability since his first days in office nearly one year ago. But it’s clear that his pledge does not apply to torture committed by officials from the Bush administration. And that’s the point the ACLU made shortly after Obama’s acceptance speech in Oslo
* 416 diggs
Innocent Guantanamo Torture Victim Finally Released

What makes this story even more shocking is that al-Rabiah's innocence was established in the summer of 2002, when a CIA analyst and an Arabic expert interviewed him as part of a fact-finding mission to Guantánamo, which revealed that a large number of the men held "had no connection to terrorism whatsoever."
* 422 diggs
Revealed: War Fraud Whistleblowers Under Wraps

One of the reasons for the high costs of maintaining each soldier is the lack of oversight of private contractor billings over the course of these two wars. The DOD, and the Army, has fought the auditors and the investigators in the military who have attempted to expose fraud, waste, overbillings and other abuses of costs in contractor contracts.
* 457 diggs
t r u t h o u t | California's Medical Marijuana Law - Just

overview of the history of CA's Medical Marijuana laws.
* 360 diggs
Abortion Amendment May Sink Health Care Bill

The Stupak-Pitts Amendment, barring private and public health insurance plans from offering abortions as part of basic coverage if they accept government subsidies, risks sinking the fragile health bill passed Saturday. President Obama and numerous Democrats say they will not support its passage with the amendment included.
* 218 diggs
t r u t h o u t | HEALTH CARE DEBATE LIVE COVERAGE: Democrat

Truthout follows Saturday's debate in Congress over the historic health care vote.
* 851 diggs
How to Destroy the Government in Three Easy Steps

Excellent piece!
* 1917 diggs
Halburton concentration camps being built for "new programs" of Bush.

This should be headline news but then again the Bush regime never ceases to amaze me.Over 600 concentration camps have been or are being built around the US and Cheney's company conveniently won a 385 million dollar contract to make even more.
* 1538 diggs
Pentagon Sued Over Mandatory Christianity

A military watchdog organization filed a lawsuit in federal court Tuesday against the Pentagon, Secretary of Defense Robert Gates, and a US Army major, on behalf of an Army soldier stationed in Iraq. The suit charges the Pentagon with widespread constitutional violations by allegedly trying to force the soldier to embrace evangelical Christianity a
* 781 diggs
How Many More Bush Appointees to Walk?

Just how many high profile Bush appointees will be asked to resign, or will resign of their own accord before Americans catch on that this boat is aflame and sinking and decide to impeach Bush/Cheney? Something's gone very very wrong and the rats are jumping ship. Time to do the right thing America. ImpeachBush.Org

Powered by Digg's Users


LATEST STORIES

*
HAITI LIVE BLOG DAY 3: FAA Halts All Air Trafic to Haiti, Citing Lack of Fuel and No Room for Planes
*
HAITI EARTHQUAKE LIVE BLOG: Who to Follow and What to Read for Breaking Developments
*
Ten Things the US Can and Should Do for Haiti
*
Haiti: How to Help
*
666 to 1: The US Military, Al-Qaeda and a War of Futility
*
Froma Harrop | Google's Heroism (Sort of), Self-Interest and Parasitism
*
Obama to Unveil Bank Fee to Cover Bailout Losses: Official

Click here for more top stories




Digg
What is Digg?
Upcoming Truthout stories on Digg.

* 34 diggs
Army Files Charges Against Single Mother

The Army has filed charges for a special court-martial against Spc. Alexis Hutchinson, a single mother of a one-year-old baby. Hutchinson missed her deployment to Afghanistan late last year when her child-care plans for her son, Kamani, fell through at the last minute.
* 8 diggs
Speaking Truth to Power

What has the US invasion and occupation unleashed in Iraq, Afghanistan and Pakistan? And how are these wars creating security for US people?
* 5 diggs
Ten Things the US Can and Should Do for Haiti

FTA: "Nine. Require that all the nongovernmental organizations which raise money in the US be transparent about what they raise, where the money goes, and insist that they be legally accountable to the people of Haiti. Ten. Treat all Haitians as we ourselves would want to be treated."
* 4 diggs
HAITI EARTHQUAKE LIVE BLOG:

5:00 pm PDT: I just posted a video containing raw aerial footage captured by the Coast Guard of the devastation on the ground in Haiti. Check it out
* 2 diggs
Why Obama Must Take On Wall Street

FTA: "the widening gulf between Wall Street and Main Street – a big bail-out for the former, unemployment checks for the latter; high profits and giant bonuses for the former, job and wage losses for the latter; ... is dangerous."

Powered by Digg's Users